[Neurons] 2012 Meta Reflections #48

[L. Michael Hall]

From: L. Michael Hall

Meta Reflections 2012  #48

Sept. 24, 2012

Empowerment Series #32

 

 

THE POWER OF TESTING THINGS

 

 

I like NLP because it is a pragmatic discipline and one that encourages the
testing of things.  If you read the original NLP books, the originators
constantly urged this:

"Don't take our word for things, test it for yourself.  See if it works for
you.  If something does not work for you, keep refining it so that you
customize it for you, or try something else."

 

We test things constantly because if something isn't working, maybe we have
not applied the proper skills or maybe we do not yet have an accurate map of
things.  Korzybski (1933/ 1994) emphasized that a mental map was only as
good as it could be used to navigate the territory.  If your mental maps is
not taking you to the places you want to go and giving you the experiences
you want to have- do one of two things: 

          First, check the map to see if it is accurate and appropriate.

          Second, check your skills to see if you have the appropriate
competencies for using your map to navigate a certain domain.

 

Testing your map against reality in terms of what works, what does not work,
what works poorly, what works effectively is a practical way to determine
pragmatic truth.  This is not absolute "truth."  It is not truth with a
capital T.  It is the truth of a situation, of a given context and time.

 

Now I write all of that because of the confusion and myths and non-sense
that's perpetuated these days about "energy."  And since I've been writing
about power and empowerment, I figured it's time to address some of these.
The first on a controversial methodology that lots of NLP people have gotten
into.  You may not like what you are about to read.  Yet if you are
committed to testing things and not just blindly believing things, then I
invite you to read with an open mind and check it out.

 

The story begins in 1996 when Emily Rosa watched a videotape with her mother
on the growing industry called "therapeutic touch," a controversial method
of treating ailments by manipulating the patients' "energy fields."  While a
patient would lay still, a therapist would move his or her hands just inches
away from the patient's body to detect and remove "undesirable energies,"
which according to those who practice this controversial method would
presumably caused various illnesses.

 

Now Emily suggested to her mother that she might be able to conduct an
experiment on such a claim.  Linda Rosa, her mother was a nurse and
long-standing member of the National Council Against Health Fraud gave her
some advice on the method.

So this is what Emily did.  She initially recruited 21 therapists and set up
a test.  The test involved Emily and the therapist sitting on opposites
sides of a table with a cardboard screen separating them.  The cardboard
screen blocked both of their views so that neither of them could see the
other. The screen had holes cut out at the bottom through which the
therapist would place her hands, palms up, and out of sight.  Emily would
flip a coin and, based on the result, placed her hand four to five inches
over the therapist's left or right hand.  (This distance was marked on the
screen so that Emily's hand would be at a consistent distance from the
therapist's hand.)  Then the therapists, unable to see Emily, would have to
determine whether she was holding her hand over their left or right hand by
feeling for her energy field.  Emily reported her results at the science
fair and received a blue ribbon for her science project.

 

Some time later Emily's mother Linda mentioned this experiment to Dr.
Stephen Barrett from the NCAHF.  And he, intrigued by the simplicity of the
method and the initial findings, mentioned it to the producers of the TV
show, Scientific American Frontiers on PBS.  For that, Emily managed to
convince 7 of the original 21 therapists to take the experiment again so
that the show could be taped.  From 280 individual attempts by 21 separate
therapists to feel Emily's energy field, they correctly identified the
position of her hand just 44% of the time.  Now left to chance alone, they
should get about 50% right with a 95% confidence interval of +\- 6%.

 

With these results, Linda and Emily thought the work might be worthy of
publication.  And it was.  So in April, 1998, Emily had her experiment
published in the JAMA.  Emily reasoned that if the therapist can do what
they claimed, then they must at least be able to feel the energy field.  If
they cannot even do that, then everything about therapeutic touch would be
cast in doubt.  One of the amazing things about this is that when Emily
began, she was a 9-year-old working on this idea for her fourth-grade
science fair project.  She was 11 when her research was published and that
made her the youngest person ever to have research published in the
prestigious medical journal.  Ah, the power of testing, the power of
questioning assumptions, the power of putting a claim to the test!

 

References

Hubbard, Douglas,W. (2010). How to Measure Anything: Finding the value of
'intangibles' in business.  New York: Wiley & Sons, Inc.  pp. 13-17.

"Therapeutic Touch: Fact or Fiction?"  Nurse Week, June 7, 1998.

"A Child's Paper Poses a Medical Challenge," New York Times, April 1, 1998.

 

 

 

L. Michael Hall, Ph.D.

                Neuro-Semantics Executive Director 

                Neuro-Semantics International

P.O. Box 8

Clifton, CO. 81520 USA                             

                1 970-523-7877 

                Dr. Hall's email:
<mailto:meta at acsol.net\hich\af31506\dbch\af31505\loch\f31506> meta at acsol.net


     

     

What is Neuro-Semantic NLP?   

Neurons:  Get your free subscription to the weekly International Post on
Neuro-Semantics by Dr. L. Michael Hall. Subscribe at
<http://www.neurosemantics.com/hich/af31506/dbch/af31505/loch/f31506>
www.neurosemantics.com.  

 

Solutions:  Sign up for the Neuro-Semantic Newsletter ---
<http://newsletter.neurosemantics.com/hich/af31506/dbch/af31505/loch/f31506>
newsletter.neurosemantics.com.  This is a monthly newsletter for anyone new
to Neuro-Semantics.  Femke Stuut, Editor.

 

Coaching: For world-class Coach Training --- The Meta-Coaching System:
<http://www.meta-coaching.org/hich/af31506/dbch/af31505/loch/f31506>
www.meta-coaching.org and
<http://www.metacoachfo/hich/af31506/dbch/af31505/loch/f31506%20undation.org
/hich/af31506/dbch/af31505/loch/f31506> www.metacoachfoundation.org.
Meta-Coach Reflections sent every Wednesday to the group of Licensed
Meta-Coaches.

 

Self-Actualization: Neuro-Semantics launched the New Human Potential
Movement in 2007, for information about this, see
<http://www.self-actualizing.org/hich/af31506/dbch/af31505/loch/f31506>
www.self-actualizing.org

 

 

 

 

 

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://eight.pairlist.net/pipermail/neurons/attachments/20120924/45dc28a7/attachment.html>